What’s the Silver Bullet to Fix What’s Wrong?

When I was in ninth grade American history class, we did an interesting simulation during a unit on the Progressive Era of our country’s history. The teacher divided the class into groups, each of which was supposed to research one social reform of the time (women’s suffrage, workers’ rights, immigration reform, education) and advocate for it with the mayor of the major city in which this simulation was taking place. The goal was to have the mayor pick your group’s issue as one of the top few priorities of the city.

I was chosen mayor, which was fun, but it was a classic case of knowing what I didn’t know. I had a strong sense that certain issues would take care of other ones—that if I only picked the right issues in the right order, there would be a cascading effect on the other issues that were important in their own right but we were perhaps secondary. Trouble was, I couldn’t figure out which issues would start the dominoes falling. So I chose a broad range of things and reminded myself that it was a simulation, after all. (I can’t remember what I picked except that suffrage was definitely one of them!)

I was thinking about that this morning as I read this analysis, which argues that the negotiations over the debt ceiling have broken down. This sentence stuck out:

‎What the two parties are really doing is trying to position themselves politically to survive the consequences of their failure.

I posted the article on Facebook and commented, “That may be the most cynical thing I’ve ever read.” I don’t know anyone who doesn’t think our political system is broken (speak up if you disagree), and that statement encapsulates a lot of what’s wrong.

A short discussion resulted in which people were proposing various remedies. One person said we need term limits. I chimed in that without meaningful campaign finance reform, and also media reform, nothing else matters. A third person said, if I may quote, “My personal golden bullet is redistricting and the primary process. As long as officials can get away with only/mostly worrying about their base there’s no incentive for them to compromise.”

All worthy places to start. I’m curious. What do you think is at the heart of what’s wrong? What’s your silver bullet to fix what you find broken in our political system?

Obviously there is no one right answer but I’m wondering where various people begin to think about these things.

Photo: Some feisty women from the Progressive Era.


7 thoughts on “What’s the Silver Bullet to Fix What’s Wrong?

  1. sherry says:

    I think that the silver bullet is for ALL of US to stop demonizing those who approach problems in a different manner.

    When we as a society realize that there really is no one right answer and that most of us really do want the same end point, maybe we can open our hearts, minds and yes even wallets to move out of the quagmire and onto the recovery road.

  2. Roy Howard says:

    There is no silver bullet for the malady (sin?) that you have named. Cynicism has been steadily growing in our public life for at least forty years if not longer. The corrosive effect of widespread cynicism is something like toxic waste seeping underneath the land until everything on the surface is dying or threatened. How does a community, a congregation, a whole society rid itself of the (often invisible) waste that is threatening it? Resistance to cynicism is not a silver bullet but I think it is a crucial practice that can be taught and encouraged in our communities. And, of course, there have to be living examples of non-cynical communities of resistance whose ordinary actions sustain the common good and point toward a way of life that encourages cooperation and neighborliness. For the non-cynical, being such an visible example is still the purpose of spirit-filled congregations.

    • MaryAnn says:

      Sorta related to Roy’s point:
      My new silver bullet—and I say this only half-jokingly—is anonymous internet comments. They are the turd in the punchbowl that ruins the whole rest of the party.

  3. […] finally, for people like me who are bummed about the state of our political system, Grandpa Parker’s thoughtful kindness is a balm. […]

  4. […] This installment of link love is full of pep, so I’m sorry for the poop in the punchbowl, but as I’ve written before, the campaign spending issue drives me nuts: Because of the way we fund the campaigns that […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s